Unofficial, independent hub · not affiliated with any game studio, publisher or platform · how we work

UnverifiedThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeUpdated Nov 16, 2026 · 5 sources

Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Sparks Water Temple Debate and Record Sales

Community discussions on r/NintendoSwitch and r/Games are heating up around the Switch 2 remake of Ocarina of Time. Players are debating whether the infamous Water Temple has been made too easy or if nostalgia exaggerated its original 1998 difficulty, even as the title claims the biggest retail launch of the year in Spain.

Did the Switch 2 Remake Nerf the Water Temple?

A fan discussion on r/NintendoSwitch has sparked a debate over the difficulty of the Water Temple in the Switch 2 remake of Ocarina of Time. One player noted feeling empty after completing the dungeon, questioning whether the remake made it easy or if players just struggled more back in 1998.

The poster mentioned spending a full week telling their girlfriend, whose only prior series experience was Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom, about how brutal the dungeon would be. Worried about being labeled a nostalgic purist, the user asked the community if others had a similarly breezy experience in the new version.

The discussion touches on long-standing conversations about the structure of the franchise. On r/Games, users recently revisited a 2011 interview with GameSpot reviewer Tom McShea, who gave Skyward Sword a 7.5 and argued that Zelda needed to move away from a stale linear formula, anticipating the shift later seen in Breath of the Wild.

Record Retail Launch in Spain and Broader Discussions

Alongside gameplay debates, the title is seeing major commercial traction according to reports shared on r/NintendoSwitch. A post on the forum notes that Ocarina of Time opened with 110,900 units sold at retail in Spain, making it the biggest retail launch of the year in the region and surpassing the previous record holder, EA Sports FC 27, which sold 64.000 copies.

Meanwhile, other corners of the community are discussing the technical future of the title and the broader franchise. A thread on r/Games argued that Ocarina of Time just proved every Nintendo game is a PC game now, while fans on r/gaming have also been looking back at official promotional art from 2000 for The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask.

Two sides of the debate

The Remake Made It Too Easy

  • Finishing the Water Temple in the new Switch 2 remake left at least one returning player feeling empty compared to the original experience.
  • The dungeon failed to live up to a full week of warnings given to a newer fan who had only played Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom.

1998 Nostalgia Overhyped the Difficulty

  • The original poster admitted the possibility that players were simply less experienced in 1998 rather than the dungeon actually being brutal.
  • Critics of the classic linear dungeon experience might simply be labeled as nostalgic purists by the wider community.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: Why does the Water Temple feel easier to players in the Switch 2 remake?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Did you find the Water Temple in the Switch 2 Ocarina of Time remake easier than you remembered from 1998, or has its difficulty always been overstated?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from DevTracked

RumorGrand Theft Auto VIGTA 6 Pre-Launch Leaks: 50-Hour Story, 200-Hour Platinum & SoundtrackDays ahead of launch, insider reports, leaked review details, and preload datamines for Grand Theft Auto VI claim the game features a 50-hour main story, a 200-hour completion grind involving 170 wildlife species, and a 34-song soundtrack album.UnverifiedSteamSteam and Xbox Store Users Debate AI Disclosures and Request Better FiltersCommunity discussions on Reddit show growing frustration over how digital storefronts handle games made with generative AI. While some players want stricter filtering options to hide AI content on Steam and the Xbox store, others argue that Steam's current disclosure labels need more nuance so games are not immediately dismissed.ConfirmedXboxXbox 25th Anniversary Adds Classic Boot Animations & Sparks X25 DebateTo mark the brand's 25th anniversary, Xbox has rolled out selectable startup animations from the original 2001 console and both the 2005 and 2010 Xbox 360 eras. Alongside the software update, community members on Reddit are discussing the value and hidden details of the limited-edition 25th Anniversary Xbox Series X hardware.ConfirmedProject HelixXbox Confirms Project Helix Plays PC Games, Sparking Steam DebateXbox's next-gen chief has confirmed that Project Helix is a console first, not a PC, while noting it will be capable of playing games from a user's PC. That specific wording has triggered a major debate across the Xbox community over whether third-party storefronts like Steam are actually part of the plan, or if console business realities make that unlikely.